As a postscript to the last post, there really are two competing visions for the future, not only of American politics, but insofar as America remains the preeminent economic and military power, the future of world politics. As I think most would recognize, the two parties have become more and more irreconcilable, and it is difficult to see the differences merely or only as differences of policy preference. In a recent Politico post, for example, they title a piece "Ryan uses dark imagery to warn of Democratic Washington," they point out that his "pessimistic take on the state of the union under Democratic rule signals that Ryan — who many suspect is eyeing his own run for the White House in 2020 — is acutely aware of the anger among the GOP base that Trump rode to the nomination." He claimed that in an America under the democrats, "government is taken away from the people, and we are ruled by our betters, by a cold and unfeeling bureaucracy that replaces original thinking.” Moreover, “it is a place where the government twists the law — and the Constitution itself — to suit its purposes. A place where liberty is always under assault, where passion — the very stuff of life — is extinguished.” This is not the language that signals a policy preference for small over large government, but not unlike the ravings of Trump, this is the language of apocalypse. If it were only a matter of trimming back the federal bureaucracy, one could imagine the democrats and republicans sitting down together at a table and hammering out a compromise, but in Trump's language and now Ryan's language of apocalypse, there is no space left to hammer out policy differences. There is only the stark choice between the path of renunciation and virtue or descent into a grey abyss.
I am always a bit surprised by the fervor of such language, in part because I don't share their anger. I look around, and I don't see a place where government has been taken away from the people, only certain people, and then the republicans, who control broad swaths of the government, are perhaps even more guilty than the democrats of excluding "certain people," usually minorities, through gerrymandering, voter registration laws, and the like. I look around, and I don't see a "cold unthinking bureaucracy" replacing anything like "original thinking." No one, of course, loves a bureaucracy, and admittedly it can over-step, but I don't want to live in a world where there's lead in the gasoline polluting the air we breath, where we ignore potentially cancerous chemicals in the food we eat, and the rich have carte blanche to set the banking "rules" to their benefit. We should perhaps remember that most of the "bureaucratic rules" were put in place for a reason, good reason, and the complexity of the bureaucracy simply reflects the increasing complexity of the world we inhabit. I'm not sure they're "my betters," but I do prefer the expert advice of a trained physician over the advice of my neighbor's aunt when it comes to health issues. We live in a world where "expert advice" is needed on any number of fronts, and we ignore it at our peril. This is not to say that the "experts" are always correct -- no one believes that -- but one stands a better chance of getting better with a "real" doctor than with the neighborhood shaman, no matter how "original" or "passionate" her thinking. Could it all be "better?" Absolutely, and I have a fairly long list of what needs to be improved, but even admitting the apocalyptic rhetoric that sometimes surrounds issues of climate change and nuclear armageddon, even admitting the sometimes dire warnings about Trump himself, the democrats remain essentially "progressive" -- that is to say, grounded in a present reality, the understanding of which is abetted by physical and social science. It is a reality that can be improved, and if there is a guiding "moral" principle, one might characterize it as Kantian with a Lockian twist. In his Critique of Moral Judgement, Kant "maintained that the pursuit of the 'highest good' is not just the rational aim of all individuals, it is a necessary social aim for the human race." Having said that, of course, there is room for considerable debate on what might count as the "highest good," and so one must give it a Lockian twist. In his essay, The Reasonableness of Christianity," he hoped that "by emphasizing the moral message of the Bible, especially that of the New Testament, they could persuade Christian schismatics to tolerate one another, then perhaps to tolerate those who accepted basic moral notions without being Christian at all."
I am quoting Mark Lilla again, but if there is a central moral obligation within the democratic party, it lies in the "duty to tolerate" implicit throughout the constitution, but most blatantly in the first amendment. If I expect you to grant me free expression, then I must reciprocate and tolerate your free expression. If I expect you to grant me the freedom to worship, then again I must reciprocate and tolerate your freedom to worship. There is a hitch in this, of course, and one can ask "can one tolerate intolerance?" Much of the concern about "political correctness" flows from this question. It is ultimately a sophomoric paradox, but it plays into the current political discourse. It would seem the republicans would answer the question with a "yes," and the so-called "religious freedom" laws that would allow intolerance of homosexuality for those individuals who hold sincere religious belief condemning homosexuality. Likewise, it would seem the democrats would answer the question with a "no," and would prohibit overt expression of intolerance toward homosexuality regardless of one's individual religious belief. For the most part, this is what republicans mean when they claim that democrats twist the constitution to suit a purpose -- that democrats are waging an assault on liberty -- it is their reflexive inability to tolerate, not so much individual intolerance, but the social expression of individual intolerance regardless of its motivation. It this reflexive desire to seek "legal" prohibitions against the social expression of individual intolerance. We can ask whether a society that tolerates homosexuality is a "better" society than one that does not, of course, but in the end the ensuing debate is not one that can be settled by simply quoting prohibitions found in biblical law. Likewise, abortion. We can ask whether a society that tolerates abortion is a "better" society than one that does not, but again in the end it is not a debate that can be settled by the likes of statistics showing a strong correlation between the legalization of abortion and the decline in crime.
The impasse is real and more fundamental, and for me more frightening. If the Trump candidacy has revealed anything, it has revealed what might be called a gnostic strain in American politics. There is a sense, to use a phrase from Lilla again, "that God has abandoned the created world and left it in evil hands," and he has done so because we have tolerated the evils of homosexuality and abortion, among other things. It pictures the "highest, benign being at an infinite remove from the created world, which is governed by another malignant force," and that force is the democratic president and the fear that we will likely have another democratic president that would seek, not legal sanctions against, but rather additional legal protection for the various evils besetting us. Lilla suggests that "we can speak of a gnostic impulse within the Western religious and philosophical imagination," one expressed by "the conviction that the bonds linking God, man, and world have been severed and can be restored only through a kind of spiritual exercise cultivating the divine spark within the human soul or mind" -- one might add, the individual soul or mind that repudiates a "political correctness" aligned with the malignant forces governing the world. Christianity, particularly evangelical protestant christianity, "has been plagued by the gnostic temptation since its inception," and its not surprising. Evangelical christianity is a religion that "teaches its followers to look to their hearts rather than the Law," and so we have Ryan saying, "We have the chance to save this country from decline and set it back on the right path — a path lit with hope, liberty, and self-determination." It is a religion that assures its followers that "they are the salt of the earth and light of the world," and so we have Ryan saying, “The kind of America we want is confident and determined … is a land of opportunity, driven by the individual spirit." And of course when one is "driven by the individual spirit," personal happiness and economic prosperity are sure to follow: "You don’t just live your life, you lead your life. You don’t just get by, you get ahead.”
All of which is great, but what is missing from Ryan's rhetoric is any sense of the heresy he is promoting. Lilla suggests that, "as orthodox theory sees it, the heretical danger of gnosticism is double." As the first danger, "it encourages Christians to think they can directly encounter the devine without the intercession of Christ or the church." There would seem to be little danger of forsaking christ, or for that matter, a church (if not the church) at least within the US. Or so it would seem. The mythos of the crucified Christ translates well into the current political discourse, and the christ proper, the divine redeemer, has been usurped by his terrestrial surrogate, the political redeemer. There is Washington as a stand-in for the biblical Rome and its alignment with the jewish elite. Rome was a malignant global empire, set against the chosen people of Israel, and so you have the likes of Alec Jones saying, “the globalists are building a world, in their own words, where normal human life is over,” he ranted. “It’s the devil. The churches are not going to tell you. It’s an alien force, not of this world, attacking humanity, like the Bible and every other ancient text says.” The churches -- at least the mainstream churches -- are not likely to talk about "alien forces," in part because they themselves are seen as part of the global conspiracy, but one can find the truth for one's self. There remains the appeal to biblical authority, which, if read correctly, reveals the truth, and Jones will be there to help you read it correctly. Although one might question whether Trump has gone full Jones, his rhetoric nevertheless bears a remarkable similarity. “This is a conspiracy against you, the American people, and we cannot let this happen or continue," he said, a conspiracy mounted by "corrupt media pushing false allegations and outright lies in an effort to elect Hillary Clinton president." Trump adds, “This is our moment of reckoning as a society and as a civilization itself,” and then there is Trump himself as the victimized stand-in for Christ, who sacrificed himself for the good of all. “I take all of these slings and arrows gladly for you," he said, "I take them for our movement so that we can have our country back,” he said. His victory promises the reconciliation and redemption promised by the second coming. If he loses? Well, he cannot lose, and if he DOES lose the election, it will simply be further evidence that the whole system is "rigged" against him, further proof that there exists a vast, global conspiracy against the people.
So what to do? As the second danger of gnosticism, "it tells them that they must either withdraw from a hopelessly fallen and alien world, or transform it utterly through the unique knowledge they possess." One can see a more complete withdrawal in the likes of a David Koresh, another terrestrial surrogate, but the political redeemer plays on the world stage and so there is no hope except the hope for total transformation. As it translates into the current political discourse, however, the withdrawal from the fallen and alien world becomes "America First." It is not exactly isolationist, as Trump would have it, but it is certainly antagonistic, demanding that our now traditional allies in NATO and Asia pay more as their fair share for American protection. Although he does call for a rebuilding of American forces, particularly our nuclear forces, altogether there is a sense of withdrawal behind walls mostly to expel and then keep out the "alien force, not of this world, attacking humanity." The infamous Mexican border wall being a case in point. As Lilla suggested, gnosticism is "fueled in its adherents' minds by the awareness and experience of suffering," and there is reason to believe the white working class is suffering, if not exactly the pangs of actual deprivation, then the loss of status relative to the growing presence and increasing demographic importance of non-white minorities. Ultimately, however, by placing "America first," the rhetoric suggests a hopelessly fallen and alien America that Trump will transform utterly and redeem through his unique knowledge and presence. He will, as his hats proclaim, "make America great again." At his rallies, Trump presents himself, to use Lilla's phrase, as a messianic figure urging his followers "to destroy the present satanic order, or to bring on the apocalypse by embracing sin," or some combination of the two. That he has little in the way of policy prescriptions for what follows on the destruction of the present order is largely irrelevant. His is a "faith based" movement, and just as the local pastor demands that we place our faith in the redemptive quality of Christ, there is a corresponding demand that we place our faith in the redemptive quality of Trump. If Trump's lack of "political correctness" and outright "pussy grabbing" vulgarity makes him seem more anti-christ than christ, so be it. Republican voters seem willing to embrace and forgive his sin -- his humanity -- so long as the destroys the present order.
Having said this, we will wake up on November 9th. If Clinton wins, I don't think anyone is expecting a miraculous transformation. If Trump wins, however, American will suddenly, miraculously be redeemed and restored to its former glory -- not! The world of November 8th will still be with us on November 9th, and as I've said many times before, Trump will face the prospect, not of becoming, but being president. There will still be a looming majority of black and brown people and the lingering stench of racism and xenophobia -- there will still be an uncertain and threatening world in North Korea, the Middle East, and Eastern Europe and looming prospect of nuclear proliferation within rogue states -- there will still be a "global economy" that resists description and manipulation from a thousand different directions -- and there will still be the governing imperative to "do something!"-- the political demand to "make it better!" On the assumption that he is not vested with supernatural powers, what exactly will Trump do? No one knows exactly, but one can be reasonably assured it will not be the republican platform as Ryan and the other "elites" understand it -- some of it perhaps, but not all of it, and most of it without real ideological commitment.
Ryan did, however, ask the right question: "Are we are going to be positive and inclusive, bring people together, and reclaim our founding principles?" One of the founding principles was what Lilla called the "great separation" between church and state. "Messianism, apocalypticism, chiliasm, political eschatology -- there are many terms to describe these religious impulses and how they take political form" -- and they always, without exception, lead to disaster. The American founders, however,
have made a choice that is at once simpler and harder: we have chosen to limit our politics to protecting individuals from the worst harms they can inflict on one another, to securing fundamental liberties and providing for their basic welfare, while leaving their spiritual destinies in their own hands. We have wagered that it is wiser to beware the forces unleashed by the Bible's messianic promise than to try exploiting them for the public good. We have chosen to keep our politics unilluminated by the light of revelation. If our experiment is to work, we must rely on our own lucidity.
Ryan knows we should beware the forces of messianic promise, and his hesitancy in the face of Trump demonstrates that he knows such forces, unleashed, bode ill for our experiment in democracy. As the common wisdom has it, Ryan is betting on a Trump loss, but doesn't want that loss to extend to the congress. Whether he has done so out of despair or with calculating cynicism, however, his recent adoption of Trump's tone shows him more than willing to exploit Trump's apocalyptic vision for what he believes to be in the public good, even if he hasn't fully accepted Trump as his savior and redeemer. Nevertheless, if the republican party is to become "positive and inclusive," if it is to "bring people together," ultimately it must reject the apocalyptic tone and the messianic Trump. It should, indeed, reclaim our founding principles, and rely not only on its own lucidity, but the lucidity of the American people to address the present reality.
Sunday, October 16, 2016
Friday, October 14, 2016
Evil and Redemption
Over the past few days, I have been in Nebraska visiting my dad. He is 84 years old, and his health is deteriorating by fits and stumbles. He contracted pneumonia nearly two years ago, broke a hip falling off his scooter, and then had a recurrence of pneumonia, from which it is unlikely his lungs will ever fully recover. He is tethered to an oxygen machine. Without it, he is instantly breathless. With it, he still struggles to get back and forth from the toilet, a trip he makes frequently because his physicians also have him taking a diuretic for a congestive heart. Although one can hope for the best, and there was little "death talk" between us, the visit was really a farewell visit. We may not see him alive again.
I mention my dad for a couple of reasons, not least that I haven't fully processed the idea that I am rapidly slipping into the "elder generation." The baby boom was so long associated with youth and rebellion that, as a member of that generation, it is difficult to think of myself as anything but young and rebellious with time enough and a world to reform. When my father passes, however, I will be the eldest living survivor in my immediate family -- the next in line for death. With that, perhaps, I should come to terms with my own mortality? Admittedly, I haven't given it much thought, though I have come to terms with one salient idea -- there is no afterlife. After death, after consciousness goes dark, there is nothing -- no heaven, no hell, nothing at all, at least for me. This is a deeply troubling idea for many. I know, because Lora finds it very troubling that the "me," all that "I am" will pass away into the fading memories of our children and grandchildren, then oblivion. Meanwhile, life goes on.
It's troubling, of course, because the idea of our own absence is simply inconceivable. There is a paradoxical hitch (pun intended, but I'll come back to that) in our consciousness that immediately bifurcates into two parts, the world outside that is contemplated and the world inside that contemplates. We can, perhaps, wrap our head around the idea that the world outside dissolves into nothing, but we cannot shut down the consciousness that contemplates oblivion. No matter where I go, in fact or in thought, there I am, perceiving, thinking, feeling, and anything without my perceiving, thinking, feeling presence is, quite literally, inconceivable. Wrap my head around oblivion how I might, I am always there in the dark, along with Descarte, thinking about nothing, and feeling a sense of what? partly dread, partly awe at what? the emptiness of space.
It's troubling too because it suggests a follow on idea -- that "this is it." There are any number of threads to unravel in this idea, but I'd like to touch on just one -- the notion that this life is a sort of preliminary "testing" ground for the next. I have to admit, I very much like the idea that there is an afterlife where good is rewarded and evil is punished, because in this life -- let's face it -- it seems no good deed goes unpunished and mundane evil seems to prosper. No one thinks of themselves as evil, or at least irredeemably evil, so it's always comforting to believe we will be rewarded for enduring the trials and tribulations of this life in the next. It is perhaps even more comforting to think that the assholes who made us miserable will get their just deserts roasting in an ocean of eternal fire. If there is no afterlife, there is likewise no divine reward and retribution. This, with all its trials and tribulations, is it. This idea is troubling because it would seem to remove all sense of moral imperative. Why be good if no good deed goes unpunished? Then too, it seems even to condone the worst sorts of hedonism. So long as I can get away with it, I should eat, drink, and fuck my way to oblivion, even if the meat and wine are stolen and the sex non-consenual. Why not? particularly if it gives "me" pleasure and makes "me" happy in the here and now?
There are any number of answers to this question, but most come down to a sense of social reciprocity. I am not fond of losing my sustenance to thievery, so I enter into a social contract with others promising not to sexually harass their daughters if they refrain from harassing my grand-daughter. One can imagine the social contract extending to encompass the full extent of the extent of the existing law, the row upon row of books that line a judges chambers, and generally speaking when we submit to the "rule of law," we are merely suggesting that we are parties to the current status quo of an on-going social contract. Here, I might add that many of the laws extant in the current status quo might reflect biblical antecedents, the social contract itself is purely secular. We take on full responsibility for its creation, its administration over time, and its enforcement. From there, of course, all sorts of complexities emerge. What sort of "laws" should be passed and why? Just who exactly gets to create the social contract? Who gets to administer it and how? And finally, who gets to enforce it and how? Because it is not the immutable and infallible word of god, the social contract evolves over time, along with the morality that supports it, and of course this evolution can be disconcerting to those who do not approve of particular changes. On the one hand, we have, as a nation, grown more tolerant of gay sexuality. The movement to extend marriage to gay couples would have been inconceivable during my adolescence. On the other hand, we have, as a nation, grown less tolerant of "non-consensual sex," whether it is non-consenual by definition (e.g. adult sex with a minor) or simply uninvited sexual aggression. The movement to extend protections against sexual harassment likewise would have been inconceivable during my adolescence.
Which brings me back and around to the republican party. It's their party, and they can cry if they want to, but recent revelations of Trump making crude comments to Billy Bush are hardly surprising to anyone with anything like an objective view of his character. First, he portrays himself as a hedonist enabled by privilege. As a metaphor of just how privilege works, Trump's alleged behavior at the Miss Teen USA patent is a case in point. As BuzzFeed reports it, "Trump, who owned the Miss Universe, Miss USA, and Miss Teen USA pageants from 1996 until last year, has publicly bragged about invading beauty queen dressing rooms, calling it one of his prerogatives of ownership." His "invasion" has been corroborated by several of the contestants of the Miss Teen pageant, four of whom "said Donald Trump walked into the dressing room while contestants — some as young as 15 — were changing. 'I remember putting on my dress really quick because I was like, ‘Oh my god, there’s a man in here,' said Mariah Billado, the former Miss Vermont Teen USA. Three other women, who asked to remain anonymous for fear of getting engulfed in a media firestorm, also remembered Trump entering the dressing room while girls were changing. Two of them said the girls rushed to cover their bodies, with one calling it 'shocking' and 'creepy.' The third said she was clothed and introduced herself to Trump." Although 11 other women questioned did not see Trump in their changing room, the report nevertheless has credibility because his public bragging is not merely a matter of private recall, but was aired publicly and exists on tape. “I’ll tell you the funniest is that I’ll go backstage before a show and everyone’s getting dressed,” Trump told Howard Stern in recordings released Saturday by CNN. “No men are anywhere, and I’m allowed to go in, because I’m the owner of the pageant and therefore I’m inspecting it. … ‘Is everyone OK?’ You know, they’re standing there with no clothes. ‘Is everybody OK?’ And you see these incredible looking women, and so I sort of get away with things like that.”
Second, though he has bragged publicly about it, he knows, or ought to know as a business owner, that such behavior is now illegal. By almost any definition, it is sexual harassment. In the case of the Teen pageant, it is compounded by the ages of the perpetrator and the victims. It is an adult's sexual harassment of a minor. Nevertheless, his public bragging does indicate one thing -- he considers himself outside and above the normal boundaries of social reciprocity. He is not "one of us," but in a separate class. One hopes he would not have considered such behavior "appropriate" had another hedonist, enabled by privilege, been the pageant owner and his own daughter Ivanka had been the recipient of his gawking. Although it received some criticism, the repudiations of Trump that began "as the father of daughters" is at least an implicit recognition of the boundaries of social reciprocity -- they would not want to subject their daughters to leering eyes of one like Trump and so they must refrain from such behavior themselves and condemn it in others. It's hardly surprising that Trump would barely acknowledging responsibility -- characterizing his assertion that he could "grab them by the pussy" as mere locker room banter while providing the pre-pubescent excuse that "everyone does it" as his moral and ethical justification. It's perhaps more surprising that the party of moral rectitude, the party of law and order, is so willing to forgive him. As the Times reports, under the headline banner "Some in G.O.P. Who Deserted Donald Trump Over Lewd Tape Are Returning," one must ask why? Part of it is a self-serving party loyalty, coupled with the expectation that he will lose regardless, and so they themselves have themselves nothing to lose in supporting those aspects of his agenda that might resemble a "generic republican agenda." Senator John Thune of South Dakota, for example, said on Saturday "that Mr. Pence should be the party’s nominee, 'effective immediately,' acknowledged that the recording of Mr. Trump boasting of grabbing women’s genitals was 'more offensive than anything that I had seen' from the often-inflammatory Republican standard-bearer. But he said in an interview Tuesday with KELO television in Sioux Falls, S.D., that he would still cast his ballot for Mr. Trump. 'I intend to support the nominee of our party, and if anything should change, then I’ll let you know,' Mr. Thune said. 'But he’s got a lot of work to do, I think, if he’s going to have any hope of winning this election.'”
He's got a lot of work to do? Well, of course he does. Pence suggested that we should "forgive Trump." As USA today reports, "'As Christians we are called to forgive, even as we've been forgiven,' Pence said during a speech atLiberty University in Lynchburg, Va. , as he proceeded to praise Trump's handling of the matter at the recent debate in St. Louis against Hillary Clinton ." If he really wants to be forgiven, however, part of that work is personal transformation, or as the evangelical christians would have it, being "reborn in christ." Christianity Today reports an interview with Mike Huckabee who "referred to the close relationship between televangelist Paula White and Trump, calling her his 'spiritual counselor and advisor.'” How she counsels and advises him is a matter of speculation, but a key aspect of the conversion experience is repentance, and Trump famously shows few signs of repentance because, one suspects, he sincerely believes there is little for which he must repent. Although he disavowed his comments, he nevertheless dismissed his comments to Billy Bush as locker room banter, showing no sign of remorse and even fewer signs that he had spoken with a spiritual counselor, even one as self-promoting as Paula White, who likely would have advised him to say "that was the old me, but the new me in christ would no longer say or do such a thing." As James Dobson has put it, at best we might think of Trump as a "baby christian" who "doesn't have a clue about how believers think, talk and act." With such scant evidence of an actual conversion experience and the subsequent repentance for the evils of one's past, perhaps one has to turn to Trump's stance on single issues -- abortion in particular -- to have a rational basis to support Trump on religious grounds.
Dobson, however, may well have missed the point. Trump may well know better than he how "believers think, talk and act." Trump, one suspects, may well have tapped into something more primal than the white bread televangelism that has come to represent christianity in the modern world -- tapped into what Mark Lilla called the "third stream of christian political theology," the "messianic and apocalyptic elements of the faith which in the right circumstances can be shaped into an eschatological vision of political life." He goes on to suggest that "by reading scripture esoterically and symbolically, these enthusiasts detect a chain of clues, apparent only to adepts, revealing the divine plan for tribulations, the destruction of the world, and the establishment of a new order under Jesus Christ, where peace and justice will finally reign." There is a parallel between the mind-set that reads the bible "esoterically and symbolically" and those who read bits and pieces of current events in the same way, detecting a chain of clues, revealing secret plans, most of which are malignant and aimed, if not at the destruction of the world, at the destruction of American "culture." It is the gnostic world of Alex Jones and Infowars, not to mention Steve Bannon and Breitbart, for which Trump and no doubt many of his followers share an affinity. Mark Lilla goes on to write about the "third stream," pointing out that it has deep affinities with the apolitical stream of Christian theology because it shares a sense of God's remoteness, which explains why ours is a time of tribulation." Here again, there is a parallel between those who have a sense of God's withdrawal, his displeasure with the way things are going, and those who believe the white house has been usurped by a black muslim in league with ISIS, not to mention the abortionists and the queers, and all the other forces out to destroy us. Such thinking is not political in the proper sense of the word -- that is to say, it does not consider the "principles of the present order and how it might be improved" -- rather, as Lilla points out, "it is political only in the sense that it imagines the church [and country] to be living the last days, and it dreams of one final political act or one last ruler who will bring the present order to an end, delivering us into a time when we will have no need for politics" or, for that matter, politicians.
Dobson, that is, missed the point -- the redeemer does not need redemption. Trump believes in the messiah, but not the white, anti-tax, anti-abortion, anti-gay Jesus whose natural habitat is the clubhouse at the more exclusive republican resorts. Though one doubts that even he would be foolish enough to put it quite this way, Trump, rather, believes he IS the messiah. In response to the allegations of sexual harassment, he does not demonstrate repentance, but rather, as Salon put it, "goes full Breitbart." They see "a pattern thus far from Republican presidential nominee Trump in which he reacts to bad campaign news by sounding increasingly authoritarian and conspiratorial, and today was a continuation of that theme." Not unlike the christ of the scriptures, he pulls out his whip and goes after the money lenders in the temple. At his Mar-a-Lago resort, "Trump opened up his remarks by claiming that a global cabal of shadowy 'special interests' had looted the American economy and destroyed local manufacturing. 'The Clinton machine is at the center of this power structure,' Trump said, adding, 'We’ve seen this first hand in the WikiLeaks documents, in which Hillary Clinton meets in secret with international banks to plot the destruction of U.S. sovereignty in order to enrich these global financial powers, her special-interest friends and her donors.'” Ultimately, such rhetoric appeals to an "antinomian impulse," and as Salon notes, is sometimes described as as “New World Order” conspiracy theories. Such conspiracy theories, according to the NY Times Magazine, "is not so much a single plot as a way of reading history. At its most basic level: A cabal, working in secret as well as through official-seeming, above-ground means, seeks to establish an all-powerful, possibly Luciferian, one-world government." Donald Trump, and Donald Trump alone, or so he sincerely seems to believe, can save us from such apocalyptic calamity. If there is something slightly unhinged about such rhetoric, and there is, it is nothing new. The Times details 50 years of conspiracy theories, and Lilla reminds us that "the messianic impulse has remained strong, if inconstant, in the biblical faiths, breaking out regularly in periods of despair and crises." Though it's difficult to see just where the crises lies, or to fully understand the despair, it does paint the contrast between Trump and Clinton in stark terms. The antinomian, messianic impulse, as Lilla writes, has inspired many things, but it has never inspired "sober reflection on political life and how that life might be gradually improved in the here and now." If Clinton is anything, she is the policy wonk that reflects too deeply (if that is possible) on the political status quo and how that might be improved in the here and now.
I mention my dad for a couple of reasons, not least that I haven't fully processed the idea that I am rapidly slipping into the "elder generation." The baby boom was so long associated with youth and rebellion that, as a member of that generation, it is difficult to think of myself as anything but young and rebellious with time enough and a world to reform. When my father passes, however, I will be the eldest living survivor in my immediate family -- the next in line for death. With that, perhaps, I should come to terms with my own mortality? Admittedly, I haven't given it much thought, though I have come to terms with one salient idea -- there is no afterlife. After death, after consciousness goes dark, there is nothing -- no heaven, no hell, nothing at all, at least for me. This is a deeply troubling idea for many. I know, because Lora finds it very troubling that the "me," all that "I am" will pass away into the fading memories of our children and grandchildren, then oblivion. Meanwhile, life goes on.
It's troubling, of course, because the idea of our own absence is simply inconceivable. There is a paradoxical hitch (pun intended, but I'll come back to that) in our consciousness that immediately bifurcates into two parts, the world outside that is contemplated and the world inside that contemplates. We can, perhaps, wrap our head around the idea that the world outside dissolves into nothing, but we cannot shut down the consciousness that contemplates oblivion. No matter where I go, in fact or in thought, there I am, perceiving, thinking, feeling, and anything without my perceiving, thinking, feeling presence is, quite literally, inconceivable. Wrap my head around oblivion how I might, I am always there in the dark, along with Descarte, thinking about nothing, and feeling a sense of what? partly dread, partly awe at what? the emptiness of space.
It's troubling too because it suggests a follow on idea -- that "this is it." There are any number of threads to unravel in this idea, but I'd like to touch on just one -- the notion that this life is a sort of preliminary "testing" ground for the next. I have to admit, I very much like the idea that there is an afterlife where good is rewarded and evil is punished, because in this life -- let's face it -- it seems no good deed goes unpunished and mundane evil seems to prosper. No one thinks of themselves as evil, or at least irredeemably evil, so it's always comforting to believe we will be rewarded for enduring the trials and tribulations of this life in the next. It is perhaps even more comforting to think that the assholes who made us miserable will get their just deserts roasting in an ocean of eternal fire. If there is no afterlife, there is likewise no divine reward and retribution. This, with all its trials and tribulations, is it. This idea is troubling because it would seem to remove all sense of moral imperative. Why be good if no good deed goes unpunished? Then too, it seems even to condone the worst sorts of hedonism. So long as I can get away with it, I should eat, drink, and fuck my way to oblivion, even if the meat and wine are stolen and the sex non-consenual. Why not? particularly if it gives "me" pleasure and makes "me" happy in the here and now?
There are any number of answers to this question, but most come down to a sense of social reciprocity. I am not fond of losing my sustenance to thievery, so I enter into a social contract with others promising not to sexually harass their daughters if they refrain from harassing my grand-daughter. One can imagine the social contract extending to encompass the full extent of the extent of the existing law, the row upon row of books that line a judges chambers, and generally speaking when we submit to the "rule of law," we are merely suggesting that we are parties to the current status quo of an on-going social contract. Here, I might add that many of the laws extant in the current status quo might reflect biblical antecedents, the social contract itself is purely secular. We take on full responsibility for its creation, its administration over time, and its enforcement. From there, of course, all sorts of complexities emerge. What sort of "laws" should be passed and why? Just who exactly gets to create the social contract? Who gets to administer it and how? And finally, who gets to enforce it and how? Because it is not the immutable and infallible word of god, the social contract evolves over time, along with the morality that supports it, and of course this evolution can be disconcerting to those who do not approve of particular changes. On the one hand, we have, as a nation, grown more tolerant of gay sexuality. The movement to extend marriage to gay couples would have been inconceivable during my adolescence. On the other hand, we have, as a nation, grown less tolerant of "non-consensual sex," whether it is non-consenual by definition (e.g. adult sex with a minor) or simply uninvited sexual aggression. The movement to extend protections against sexual harassment likewise would have been inconceivable during my adolescence.
Which brings me back and around to the republican party. It's their party, and they can cry if they want to, but recent revelations of Trump making crude comments to Billy Bush are hardly surprising to anyone with anything like an objective view of his character. First, he portrays himself as a hedonist enabled by privilege. As a metaphor of just how privilege works, Trump's alleged behavior at the Miss Teen USA patent is a case in point. As BuzzFeed reports it, "Trump, who owned the Miss Universe, Miss USA, and Miss Teen USA pageants from 1996 until last year, has publicly bragged about invading beauty queen dressing rooms, calling it one of his prerogatives of ownership." His "invasion" has been corroborated by several of the contestants of the Miss Teen pageant, four of whom "said Donald Trump walked into the dressing room while contestants — some as young as 15 — were changing. 'I remember putting on my dress really quick because I was like, ‘Oh my god, there’s a man in here,' said Mariah Billado, the former Miss Vermont Teen USA. Three other women, who asked to remain anonymous for fear of getting engulfed in a media firestorm, also remembered Trump entering the dressing room while girls were changing. Two of them said the girls rushed to cover their bodies, with one calling it 'shocking' and 'creepy.' The third said she was clothed and introduced herself to Trump." Although 11 other women questioned did not see Trump in their changing room, the report nevertheless has credibility because his public bragging is not merely a matter of private recall, but was aired publicly and exists on tape. “I’ll tell you the funniest is that I’ll go backstage before a show and everyone’s getting dressed,” Trump told Howard Stern in recordings released Saturday by CNN. “No men are anywhere, and I’m allowed to go in, because I’m the owner of the pageant and therefore I’m inspecting it. … ‘Is everyone OK?’ You know, they’re standing there with no clothes. ‘Is everybody OK?’ And you see these incredible looking women, and so I sort of get away with things like that.”
Second, though he has bragged publicly about it, he knows, or ought to know as a business owner, that such behavior is now illegal. By almost any definition, it is sexual harassment. In the case of the Teen pageant, it is compounded by the ages of the perpetrator and the victims. It is an adult's sexual harassment of a minor. Nevertheless, his public bragging does indicate one thing -- he considers himself outside and above the normal boundaries of social reciprocity. He is not "one of us," but in a separate class. One hopes he would not have considered such behavior "appropriate" had another hedonist, enabled by privilege, been the pageant owner and his own daughter Ivanka had been the recipient of his gawking. Although it received some criticism, the repudiations of Trump that began "as the father of daughters" is at least an implicit recognition of the boundaries of social reciprocity -- they would not want to subject their daughters to leering eyes of one like Trump and so they must refrain from such behavior themselves and condemn it in others. It's hardly surprising that Trump would barely acknowledging responsibility -- characterizing his assertion that he could "grab them by the pussy" as mere locker room banter while providing the pre-pubescent excuse that "everyone does it" as his moral and ethical justification. It's perhaps more surprising that the party of moral rectitude, the party of law and order, is so willing to forgive him. As the Times reports, under the headline banner "Some in G.O.P. Who Deserted Donald Trump Over Lewd Tape Are Returning," one must ask why? Part of it is a self-serving party loyalty, coupled with the expectation that he will lose regardless, and so they themselves have themselves nothing to lose in supporting those aspects of his agenda that might resemble a "generic republican agenda." Senator John Thune of South Dakota, for example, said on Saturday "that Mr. Pence should be the party’s nominee, 'effective immediately,' acknowledged that the recording of Mr. Trump boasting of grabbing women’s genitals was 'more offensive than anything that I had seen' from the often-inflammatory Republican standard-bearer. But he said in an interview Tuesday with KELO television in Sioux Falls, S.D., that he would still cast his ballot for Mr. Trump. 'I intend to support the nominee of our party, and if anything should change, then I’ll let you know,' Mr. Thune said. 'But he’s got a lot of work to do, I think, if he’s going to have any hope of winning this election.'”
He's got a lot of work to do? Well, of course he does. Pence suggested that we should "forgive Trump." As USA today reports, "'As Christians we are called to forgive, even as we've been forgiven,' Pence said during a speech at
Dobson, however, may well have missed the point. Trump may well know better than he how "believers think, talk and act." Trump, one suspects, may well have tapped into something more primal than the white bread televangelism that has come to represent christianity in the modern world -- tapped into what Mark Lilla called the "third stream of christian political theology," the "messianic and apocalyptic elements of the faith which in the right circumstances can be shaped into an eschatological vision of political life." He goes on to suggest that "by reading scripture esoterically and symbolically, these enthusiasts detect a chain of clues, apparent only to adepts, revealing the divine plan for tribulations, the destruction of the world, and the establishment of a new order under Jesus Christ, where peace and justice will finally reign." There is a parallel between the mind-set that reads the bible "esoterically and symbolically" and those who read bits and pieces of current events in the same way, detecting a chain of clues, revealing secret plans, most of which are malignant and aimed, if not at the destruction of the world, at the destruction of American "culture." It is the gnostic world of Alex Jones and Infowars, not to mention Steve Bannon and Breitbart, for which Trump and no doubt many of his followers share an affinity. Mark Lilla goes on to write about the "third stream," pointing out that it has deep affinities with the apolitical stream of Christian theology because it shares a sense of God's remoteness, which explains why ours is a time of tribulation." Here again, there is a parallel between those who have a sense of God's withdrawal, his displeasure with the way things are going, and those who believe the white house has been usurped by a black muslim in league with ISIS, not to mention the abortionists and the queers, and all the other forces out to destroy us. Such thinking is not political in the proper sense of the word -- that is to say, it does not consider the "principles of the present order and how it might be improved" -- rather, as Lilla points out, "it is political only in the sense that it imagines the church [and country] to be living the last days, and it dreams of one final political act or one last ruler who will bring the present order to an end, delivering us into a time when we will have no need for politics" or, for that matter, politicians.
Dobson, that is, missed the point -- the redeemer does not need redemption. Trump believes in the messiah, but not the white, anti-tax, anti-abortion, anti-gay Jesus whose natural habitat is the clubhouse at the more exclusive republican resorts. Though one doubts that even he would be foolish enough to put it quite this way, Trump, rather, believes he IS the messiah. In response to the allegations of sexual harassment, he does not demonstrate repentance, but rather, as Salon put it, "goes full Breitbart." They see "a pattern thus far from Republican presidential nominee Trump in which he reacts to bad campaign news by sounding increasingly authoritarian and conspiratorial, and today was a continuation of that theme." Not unlike the christ of the scriptures, he pulls out his whip and goes after the money lenders in the temple. At his Mar-a-Lago resort, "Trump opened up his remarks by claiming that a global cabal of shadowy 'special interests' had looted the American economy and destroyed local manufacturing. 'The Clinton machine is at the center of this power structure,' Trump said, adding, 'We’ve seen this first hand in the WikiLeaks documents, in which Hillary Clinton meets in secret with international banks to plot the destruction of U.S. sovereignty in order to enrich these global financial powers, her special-interest friends and her donors.'” Ultimately, such rhetoric appeals to an "antinomian impulse," and as Salon notes, is sometimes described as as “New World Order” conspiracy theories. Such conspiracy theories, according to the NY Times Magazine, "is not so much a single plot as a way of reading history. At its most basic level: A cabal, working in secret as well as through official-seeming, above-ground means, seeks to establish an all-powerful, possibly Luciferian, one-world government." Donald Trump, and Donald Trump alone, or so he sincerely seems to believe, can save us from such apocalyptic calamity. If there is something slightly unhinged about such rhetoric, and there is, it is nothing new. The Times details 50 years of conspiracy theories, and Lilla reminds us that "the messianic impulse has remained strong, if inconstant, in the biblical faiths, breaking out regularly in periods of despair and crises." Though it's difficult to see just where the crises lies, or to fully understand the despair, it does paint the contrast between Trump and Clinton in stark terms. The antinomian, messianic impulse, as Lilla writes, has inspired many things, but it has never inspired "sober reflection on political life and how that life might be gradually improved in the here and now." If Clinton is anything, she is the policy wonk that reflects too deeply (if that is possible) on the political status quo and how that might be improved in the here and now.
Thursday, October 6, 2016
On Taxation and Trump
Every American works partly for himself, partly for the community within which he carries on his existence. One legitimate political question, of course, his how much for the individual and how much for the community? Another related legitimate question, what for the individual and what for the community?
Let me set aside one deflection before I begin. By individual, I mean what most would mean by "individual," the atomized person standing alone, but I would also include what some would call their "loved ones," their immediate family extended perhaps to a few close friends, those with whom the the atomized person interacts on a daily basis, those in whom he has a sort of emotional "property rights," the me and mine of a spouse, children, parents. One can work for the "me and mine" and feel that one is working for a gathering greater than themselves, serving a higher moral purpose, and it is true. The "me and mine" provides a more immediate and powerful incentive for the sacrifice of time and effort than any abstract other, but it is always the abstract other that carries us beyond a primitive tribalism to a civil society, a "more perfect union." We serve the "me and mine" by buying groceries and sharing them. We serve civil society by paying taxes.
There has always been a strong streak of individualism within American society, particularly within the American west. Let me set aside another deflection before I begin. By individualism, I do not mean the mere flouting social conventions -- dying one's hair purple, piercing one's nose, tattooing one's face, and then demanding equal rights to those without such accouterments. Such "individualism" is always contingent upon the social norms that it would flout. It is mostly an urban phenomenon for reasons that are easily understood. And besides, it normally passes away along with adolescence. By "individualism," rather, I mean rather that line of thinking that places sole moral authority and accountability in the individual. It is easy enough to see why such individualism has been engrained in the American psyche, particularly within the American west. As manifest destiny pushed us west into the wilderness, there was little beyond the individual and the sacrifices necessary to the survival of me and mine. If there was government, it was local government, and one could tithe to it as one tithed to the church, but the federal government was remote, was abstract, and had little bearing on the day to day struggles of the people. The mythos of "individualism" survives and can be seen in almost any western, where the individual, alone in the wilderness, is entitled, even obligated, to take up arms and protect one's own from rape and the rapine of others, those that would spoil one's women and appropriate one's land and chattel.
I am suggesting, of course, that a strong part of the republican cohort, particularly those within the west, are animated by this mythos of individualism, and a reaction to the present realities that have nibbled away at it, mostly in the form of taxes that take away subsistence that should rightly be dedicated to "me and mine" and "gives it away" to support a federal programs that remain remote, abstract, inaccessible, but increasingly intrusive. Cliven Bundy, as the exemplar du jour, is animated more by anything that would place restraints on him as an individual; hence, his support of the sovereign citizen movement that espouses mostly an "ask for nothing and give nothing" form of rebellion against the federal government. They would answer the question, how much for the individual and how much for the community, by saying "everything for the individual, nothing for the community, except those communities I, as an individual, choose to join."
I am sure I'm not the first to suggest this, and I've probably picked this particular idea up from any number of half remembered sources, but it differentiates the reaction in the west from the reaction in the south. In the south, as I have suggested, moral authority and accountability lies not in the individual, per se, but in a hierarchy that places god above man, white above black, men above women, et cetera, and the hierarchy itself creates a civil order maintained by paternal authority exercised by those above, obedience practiced by those below, or as they put it, the conservative instinct includes "a preference for homogeneity over diversity, for stability over change, and for hierarchy and order over radical egalitarianism." In the south, the political watershed that drove voters to the republican party was, of course, the civil rights and great society legislation of the Johnson era -- the first living memory of "radical egalitarianism" up-ending the natural hierarchies. The federal government was not only up-ending the natural order with the civil rights legislation, but the anti-poverty programs of the great society used tax dollars to undermine the economic hierarchy that reflected and reinforced that natural order. The question is not one of taxation, per se, but the uses to which taxation has been put, the destruction of a well ordered "community."
Although race doesn't provoke the same visceral reaction that it does in the south, if Cliven Bundy comes to sound too much like a southern cracker, for Bundy it is less a matter of hierarchy, more a matter of dependence. If the blacks were better off under slavery, as he has suggested, it is because they are "dependent" or as he put it, "they were basically on government subsidy, so now what do they do?" he asked. "They abort their young children, they put their young men in jail, because they never learned how to pick cotton. And I've often wondered, are they better off as slaves, picking cotton and having a family life and doing things, or are they better off under government subsidy? They didn't get no more freedom. They got less freedom." They violate the cardinal principle of individualism and, by his book, are better off dependent upon another individual, presumably one who can make some economic use of their dependency, than on his tax dollars. None of this makes his remarks any less deplorable, to use Clinton's word, but the point of convergence for the racial attitudes of the west and of the south is a disdain for "federal programs" and the appropriation of what is ostensibly "mine" to support them. On one side of the politicized disdain for taxes, we have a radicalized individualism and the moral rejection of dependency, particularly government dependency. On the other side, we have a radicalized "natural conservatism" and the moral rejection of egalitarianism, particularly government forced egalitarianism.
Which brings me to David Brooks. In a recent NY Times editorial, implicit to this argument is the same question that I asked at the outset, "how much for the individual and how much for the community?" He writes that, if "your primary identity is individual," then "you’re perfectly within your rights to do everything you legally can to look after your self-interest," which would include tax avoidance. "Within this logic, it’s perfectly fine for Donald Trump to have potentially paid no income taxes, even over a long period of time. As Trump and his allies have said, he would have broken no law. He would have taken advantage of the deductions just the way the rest of us take advantage of the mortgage deduction or any other; it’s just that he had more deductions to draw upon." The Daily Stormer, it seems, would agree, headlining a piece "Hey, Let’s Elect A Dumb President Who Pays More Taxes Than Owed!" Or as Brooks goes on to point out, "it is normal practice in our society to pay as little in taxes as possible. There are vast industries to help people do this. There is no wrong here."
Having said this, the present reality of the tax code is a maze of provisions that provide incentives to "desirable behavior" as well as loopholes for "special interests." Which are which is a matter of legitimate debate, but it's reasonably recognizable at the extremes. The mortgage deduction serves as an example of the former, and it incentives the desirable behavior of home ownership. Those who "follow the deductions," may have self-interest at heart, but their behavior nevertheless serves an economic and community need. On the other hand, as Steven M. Rosenthal, a real estate tax specialist and senior fellow at the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center, remarked “If it wasn’t clear before, it is now: The tax code is tilted toward the rich in its statutory framework, its exceptions, and in how it is enforced and administered.” We should not mistake of equating incentives with this "tilt toward the rich." The former serves the community, but taking advantage of the latter, even when you are behaving "legally" by the strict definition of the law, ends up "serving your individual interest short term but soiling the nest you need to be happy in over the long term," as Brooks put it. He goes on to write, "a healthy nation isn’t just an atomized mass of individual economic and legal units. A nation is a web of giving and getting. You give to your job, and your employer gives to you. You give to your neighborhood, and your neighborhood gives to you. You give to your government, and your government gives to you. If you orient everything around individual self-interest, you end up ripping the web of giving and receiving." Tax avoidance, in other words, is a way of "getting" without "giving," and "you can say that a billionaire paying no taxes is fine and legal, but "that mentality is entirely divorced from the mentality of commonality and citizenship. That mentality has side effects. They may lead toward riches, but they lead away from happiness."
His argument is fine, but it ignores two things. First, of course, it ignores Trump's "it takes one to know one" argument -- i.e. that he is "uniquely qualified" to close the very loopholes that have benefitted him so enormously. One might ask what would motivate him to do so, given that it is difficult to credit him with anything resembling pure altruism, a pure love of community and country, since he has shown little propensity in the past for anything but self-interest and self-aggrandizement. No, to be fair, there is also a strong sense of "legacy" implicit in much of what Trump does, not only serving his own heroic "legacy," but passing on that "legacy" to his children. There is nothing in this, of course, that motivates Trump to reform the tax code, and nothing that he has specifically proposed reforms the tax code to redistribute the tax burden away from the middle class toward the rich. His tax cuts, as has been amply discussed, do a little for the less fortunate, and favor those with fortunes. Overall, Trump's tax plan aims at "'reducing taxation on capital gains and high-income households,' said William Gale, a co-director of the Tax Policy Center and a former economic adviser to President George H. W. Bush." Although he favors "sharply cutting income tax rates across the board," which would impact on middle and lower income families, he also favors "reducing taxation on capital gains and high-income households." Mr. Trump would also "eliminate the estate tax (which currently applies to only about 5,300 of the richest families)" and secures his "legacy" for his children. He also proposes ending "the 3.8 percent surtax on high earners’ investment income, which helps pay for health coverage for lower-income Americans" as well as and scraping "the alternative minimum tax, which is aimed at making it harder for the affluent to take advantage of various tax breaks," precisely the opposite of "closing loopholes" for the rich. Trump's tax plan preserves and protects his "legacy," which is, I believe, essentially, a monarchical concern, or as the "the Breitbart screed for the alt-right points out that "although the alt-right consists mostly of college-educated men, it sympathizes with the white working classes and, based on our interviews, feels a sense of noblesse oblige."
Second, of course, it ignores the politically motivated antipathy toward taxes in general. When Trump leaned into the microphone and said, in response to Clinton's jab at his zero tax payment, "it would be squandered too," he rang a number of bells. Although I would be loath to call George Will a racist, there is little distance between Cliven Bundy's assertion that the decadence within the black community can be traced to their dependency on "government subsidy" and Will's more urbane assertion that "Trump’s ascendancy reflects progressivism’s success in changing America’s social norms and national character by de-stigmatizing dependency." One could argue, conversely, that Trump's ascendancy reflects conservatism's success in changing American's social norms and national character by de-stigmatizing not only the more radical forms of "individualism," that place self-interest above any sense of "taxable" obligation to one's community. One could also argue, conversely, that Trump's ascendancy reflects conservatism's success in de-stigmatizing more radical forms of inegalitarian and intolerant thought above any sense of a "taxable" obligation to make one's community more just and inclusive. Despite recent attempts to woo western voters, Trump has more in common with the alt right than the radical individualism of the west. As Will, and many of the conservative elite have recognized, but failed to acknowledge, "it's not the economy stupid." Quoting Jack Donovan's book, The Way Of Men, Breitbart complaints that "it’s tragic to think that heroic man’s great destiny is to become economic man, that men will be reduced to craven creatures who crawl across the globe competing for money, who spend their nights dreaming up new ways to swindle each other. That’s the path we’re on now." Even I would agree, it's a path to be disdained, though it is difficult to see Trump as the one who will lead us onto an alternative path. One imagines that Trump spent many nights dreaming up new ways to enrich himself, both positively in the act of acquisition and negatively in the act of tax avoidance -- at the expense of both the few and the many -- nevertheless, he presents himself as and believes himself to be the "heroic man," the charismatic leader with a "great destiny." As Breitbart goes on to point out, "for natural conservatives, culture, not economic efficiency, is the paramount value. More specifically, they value the greatest cultural expressions of their tribe," and lest you miss the point, his "tribe" is "mostly white, mostly male middle-American radicals, who are unapologetically embracing a new identity politics that prioritises the interests of their own demographic." Among his supporters, no one really cares if he didn't pay taxes -- indeed, they might actually see him as "brilliant" in avoiding taxes that would only be squandered on a "liberal" government that facilitates a debased -- that is to say, an egalitarian and inclusive -- culture.
Let me set aside one deflection before I begin. By individual, I mean what most would mean by "individual," the atomized person standing alone, but I would also include what some would call their "loved ones," their immediate family extended perhaps to a few close friends, those with whom the the atomized person interacts on a daily basis, those in whom he has a sort of emotional "property rights," the me and mine of a spouse, children, parents. One can work for the "me and mine" and feel that one is working for a gathering greater than themselves, serving a higher moral purpose, and it is true. The "me and mine" provides a more immediate and powerful incentive for the sacrifice of time and effort than any abstract other, but it is always the abstract other that carries us beyond a primitive tribalism to a civil society, a "more perfect union." We serve the "me and mine" by buying groceries and sharing them. We serve civil society by paying taxes.
There has always been a strong streak of individualism within American society, particularly within the American west. Let me set aside another deflection before I begin. By individualism, I do not mean the mere flouting social conventions -- dying one's hair purple, piercing one's nose, tattooing one's face, and then demanding equal rights to those without such accouterments. Such "individualism" is always contingent upon the social norms that it would flout. It is mostly an urban phenomenon for reasons that are easily understood. And besides, it normally passes away along with adolescence. By "individualism," rather, I mean rather that line of thinking that places sole moral authority and accountability in the individual. It is easy enough to see why such individualism has been engrained in the American psyche, particularly within the American west. As manifest destiny pushed us west into the wilderness, there was little beyond the individual and the sacrifices necessary to the survival of me and mine. If there was government, it was local government, and one could tithe to it as one tithed to the church, but the federal government was remote, was abstract, and had little bearing on the day to day struggles of the people. The mythos of "individualism" survives and can be seen in almost any western, where the individual, alone in the wilderness, is entitled, even obligated, to take up arms and protect one's own from rape and the rapine of others, those that would spoil one's women and appropriate one's land and chattel.
I am suggesting, of course, that a strong part of the republican cohort, particularly those within the west, are animated by this mythos of individualism, and a reaction to the present realities that have nibbled away at it, mostly in the form of taxes that take away subsistence that should rightly be dedicated to "me and mine" and "gives it away" to support a federal programs that remain remote, abstract, inaccessible, but increasingly intrusive. Cliven Bundy, as the exemplar du jour, is animated more by anything that would place restraints on him as an individual; hence, his support of the sovereign citizen movement that espouses mostly an "ask for nothing and give nothing" form of rebellion against the federal government. They would answer the question, how much for the individual and how much for the community, by saying "everything for the individual, nothing for the community, except those communities I, as an individual, choose to join."
I am sure I'm not the first to suggest this, and I've probably picked this particular idea up from any number of half remembered sources, but it differentiates the reaction in the west from the reaction in the south. In the south, as I have suggested, moral authority and accountability lies not in the individual, per se, but in a hierarchy that places god above man, white above black, men above women, et cetera, and the hierarchy itself creates a civil order maintained by paternal authority exercised by those above, obedience practiced by those below, or as they put it, the conservative instinct includes "a preference for homogeneity over diversity, for stability over change, and for hierarchy and order over radical egalitarianism." In the south, the political watershed that drove voters to the republican party was, of course, the civil rights and great society legislation of the Johnson era -- the first living memory of "radical egalitarianism" up-ending the natural hierarchies. The federal government was not only up-ending the natural order with the civil rights legislation, but the anti-poverty programs of the great society used tax dollars to undermine the economic hierarchy that reflected and reinforced that natural order. The question is not one of taxation, per se, but the uses to which taxation has been put, the destruction of a well ordered "community."
Although race doesn't provoke the same visceral reaction that it does in the south, if Cliven Bundy comes to sound too much like a southern cracker, for Bundy it is less a matter of hierarchy, more a matter of dependence. If the blacks were better off under slavery, as he has suggested, it is because they are "dependent" or as he put it, "they were basically on government subsidy, so now what do they do?" he asked. "They abort their young children, they put their young men in jail, because they never learned how to pick cotton. And I've often wondered, are they better off as slaves, picking cotton and having a family life and doing things, or are they better off under government subsidy? They didn't get no more freedom. They got less freedom." They violate the cardinal principle of individualism and, by his book, are better off dependent upon another individual, presumably one who can make some economic use of their dependency, than on his tax dollars. None of this makes his remarks any less deplorable, to use Clinton's word, but the point of convergence for the racial attitudes of the west and of the south is a disdain for "federal programs" and the appropriation of what is ostensibly "mine" to support them. On one side of the politicized disdain for taxes, we have a radicalized individualism and the moral rejection of dependency, particularly government dependency. On the other side, we have a radicalized "natural conservatism" and the moral rejection of egalitarianism, particularly government forced egalitarianism.
Which brings me to David Brooks. In a recent NY Times editorial, implicit to this argument is the same question that I asked at the outset, "how much for the individual and how much for the community?" He writes that, if "your primary identity is individual," then "you’re perfectly within your rights to do everything you legally can to look after your self-interest," which would include tax avoidance. "Within this logic, it’s perfectly fine for Donald Trump to have potentially paid no income taxes, even over a long period of time. As Trump and his allies have said, he would have broken no law. He would have taken advantage of the deductions just the way the rest of us take advantage of the mortgage deduction or any other; it’s just that he had more deductions to draw upon." The Daily Stormer, it seems, would agree, headlining a piece "Hey, Let’s Elect A Dumb President Who Pays More Taxes Than Owed!" Or as Brooks goes on to point out, "it is normal practice in our society to pay as little in taxes as possible. There are vast industries to help people do this. There is no wrong here."
Having said this, the present reality of the tax code is a maze of provisions that provide incentives to "desirable behavior" as well as loopholes for "special interests." Which are which is a matter of legitimate debate, but it's reasonably recognizable at the extremes. The mortgage deduction serves as an example of the former, and it incentives the desirable behavior of home ownership. Those who "follow the deductions," may have self-interest at heart, but their behavior nevertheless serves an economic and community need. On the other hand, as Steven M. Rosenthal, a real estate tax specialist and senior fellow at the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center, remarked “If it wasn’t clear before, it is now: The tax code is tilted toward the rich in its statutory framework, its exceptions, and in how it is enforced and administered.” We should not mistake of equating incentives with this "tilt toward the rich." The former serves the community, but taking advantage of the latter, even when you are behaving "legally" by the strict definition of the law, ends up "serving your individual interest short term but soiling the nest you need to be happy in over the long term," as Brooks put it. He goes on to write, "a healthy nation isn’t just an atomized mass of individual economic and legal units. A nation is a web of giving and getting. You give to your job, and your employer gives to you. You give to your neighborhood, and your neighborhood gives to you. You give to your government, and your government gives to you. If you orient everything around individual self-interest, you end up ripping the web of giving and receiving." Tax avoidance, in other words, is a way of "getting" without "giving," and "you can say that a billionaire paying no taxes is fine and legal, but "that mentality is entirely divorced from the mentality of commonality and citizenship. That mentality has side effects. They may lead toward riches, but they lead away from happiness."
His argument is fine, but it ignores two things. First, of course, it ignores Trump's "it takes one to know one" argument -- i.e. that he is "uniquely qualified" to close the very loopholes that have benefitted him so enormously. One might ask what would motivate him to do so, given that it is difficult to credit him with anything resembling pure altruism, a pure love of community and country, since he has shown little propensity in the past for anything but self-interest and self-aggrandizement. No, to be fair, there is also a strong sense of "legacy" implicit in much of what Trump does, not only serving his own heroic "legacy," but passing on that "legacy" to his children. There is nothing in this, of course, that motivates Trump to reform the tax code, and nothing that he has specifically proposed reforms the tax code to redistribute the tax burden away from the middle class toward the rich. His tax cuts, as has been amply discussed, do a little for the less fortunate, and favor those with fortunes. Overall, Trump's tax plan aims at "'reducing taxation on capital gains and high-income households,' said William Gale, a co-director of the Tax Policy Center and a former economic adviser to President George H. W. Bush." Although he favors "sharply cutting income tax rates across the board," which would impact on middle and lower income families, he also favors "reducing taxation on capital gains and high-income households." Mr. Trump would also "eliminate the estate tax (which currently applies to only about 5,300 of the richest families)" and secures his "legacy" for his children. He also proposes ending "the 3.8 percent surtax on high earners’ investment income, which helps pay for health coverage for lower-income Americans" as well as and scraping "the alternative minimum tax, which is aimed at making it harder for the affluent to take advantage of various tax breaks," precisely the opposite of "closing loopholes" for the rich. Trump's tax plan preserves and protects his "legacy," which is, I believe, essentially, a monarchical concern, or as the "the Breitbart screed for the alt-right points out that "although the alt-right consists mostly of college-educated men, it sympathizes with the white working classes and, based on our interviews, feels a sense of noblesse oblige."
Second, of course, it ignores the politically motivated antipathy toward taxes in general. When Trump leaned into the microphone and said, in response to Clinton's jab at his zero tax payment, "it would be squandered too," he rang a number of bells. Although I would be loath to call George Will a racist, there is little distance between Cliven Bundy's assertion that the decadence within the black community can be traced to their dependency on "government subsidy" and Will's more urbane assertion that "Trump’s ascendancy reflects progressivism’s success in changing America’s social norms and national character by de-stigmatizing dependency." One could argue, conversely, that Trump's ascendancy reflects conservatism's success in changing American's social norms and national character by de-stigmatizing not only the more radical forms of "individualism," that place self-interest above any sense of "taxable" obligation to one's community. One could also argue, conversely, that Trump's ascendancy reflects conservatism's success in de-stigmatizing more radical forms of inegalitarian and intolerant thought above any sense of a "taxable" obligation to make one's community more just and inclusive. Despite recent attempts to woo western voters, Trump has more in common with the alt right than the radical individualism of the west. As Will, and many of the conservative elite have recognized, but failed to acknowledge, "it's not the economy stupid." Quoting Jack Donovan's book, The Way Of Men, Breitbart complaints that "it’s tragic to think that heroic man’s great destiny is to become economic man, that men will be reduced to craven creatures who crawl across the globe competing for money, who spend their nights dreaming up new ways to swindle each other. That’s the path we’re on now." Even I would agree, it's a path to be disdained, though it is difficult to see Trump as the one who will lead us onto an alternative path. One imagines that Trump spent many nights dreaming up new ways to enrich himself, both positively in the act of acquisition and negatively in the act of tax avoidance -- at the expense of both the few and the many -- nevertheless, he presents himself as and believes himself to be the "heroic man," the charismatic leader with a "great destiny." As Breitbart goes on to point out, "for natural conservatives, culture, not economic efficiency, is the paramount value. More specifically, they value the greatest cultural expressions of their tribe," and lest you miss the point, his "tribe" is "mostly white, mostly male middle-American radicals, who are unapologetically embracing a new identity politics that prioritises the interests of their own demographic." Among his supporters, no one really cares if he didn't pay taxes -- indeed, they might actually see him as "brilliant" in avoiding taxes that would only be squandered on a "liberal" government that facilitates a debased -- that is to say, an egalitarian and inclusive -- culture.
Tuesday, October 4, 2016
A Note on Magical Thinking and Trump Supporters
The other day, I used an idea, but didn't fully attribute its source. Chauncy Devega, writing for Salon, suggested my use of the Dunning-Kruger effect to help explain why some gravitate toward simplistic solutions to complex problems or the pseudo-sophistication of the conspiracy theory. Those proposing or advocating simplistic ideas just don't see (and perhaps don't have the capacity to see) the full-blown complexity of some problems. Conspiracy theories build on a form of simplistic thinking. Physics provide a cautionary metaphor. Newtonian physics work well in the work a day world we all inhabit, but as Einstein demonstrated, they don't work well at the macro-scale where the gravity of planets and stars tub at light itself. What works well at one scale, does not necessarily work well at the macro scale. The moon landing conspiracy provides a quick case in point. Hollywood of course does have the capacity to "fake" a moon landing. One can imagine a president Kennedy being motivated to "fake" a moon landing, if for no other reason than propaganda and "bragging rights" over the soviet union. Capacity plus motivation, however, does not equal "fact," because it forgets the problem of scale. How many people would need to be involved in such a "fake" moon landing (in Hollywood alone, the people who built the set, the costumes, the actors, the photographers, the film developers and editors, the directors and producers, et cetera) and could all those people keep quiet all this time? As almost any "scandal" illustrates, even the most highly guarded secret will make its way public, particularly when there are any number of people highly motivated to "get the dirt." Of course, this lends a sense of crusading victimization and the moral high ground to conspiracy theorists who believe they DO have the dirt, but the "rigged" system run by corrupt politicians and the main-stream media that toady to the politicians are ALL conspiring to "cover up" and deny their reality. Again, a problem of scale.
Then too there's a sort of magical thinking, one that ascribes to the "great man" or the "great woman" an ability that no man or woman could possess. Let me explain. On November 15th, the day after the election, we will wake up with a new president. Regardless who that president might be, he or she will be confronted with several intractable and contentious issues. To list just a few: (1) deteriorating race relations, (2) immigration reform and war refuges, (3) the middle east and US foreign policy, to include our military interventions, (4) trade policy, (5) escalating Russian adventurism, (6) the environment, (7) the distribution of wealth and its economic effects, (8) health care, and (9) whatever else comes up. Though some of the rhetoric surrounding these problems might dissipate, none of the problems themselves will just go away after the election. No democrat that I've heard or read really believes that Clinton will come into office and the problems will simply yield to her greatness. They enumerate policy proposals that will, in one way or another, "address" the "issues." One can have, quite legitimately, different takes on each of these issues, and because they all have been with us for some time, I will venture the assumption that there are no quick and easy (no magical) solutions. No matter who takes office, there is a prevailing assumption among democrats that she will "inherit," lock stock and barrel, all of the intractable and contentious issues. No matter what one might think of her personally, she has the temperament and the policy experience to address them.
Trump supporters, however, continue to see him as the "great man," and for those of us who see nothing particularly great about him, who just don't get it, find that puzzling and disturbing. Part of it, perhaps, can be attributed to Trump himself. He sees himself as the "great man" -- I alone can solve -- and invests himself with "powers" that exceed those of normal human beings. He presents himself almost exclusively as a Charismatic Leader. George Will touches on his in his editorial the other day. “'Charismatic authority,' wrote Max Weber in 1915, seven years before Mussolini’s march on Rome, causes the governed to submit “because of their belief in the extraordinary quality of the specific person . . . . Charismatic rule thus rests upon the belief in magical powers, revelations and hero worship.' A demagogue’s success requires a receptive demos." Will, a conservative writer, blames the receptivity of his supporters on the prep work by democrats -- that is to say, "progressivism’s success in changing America’s social norms and national character by de-stigmatizing dependency." Perhaps, to some degree, but I think a bigger culprit is the religious milieu his supporters inhabit -- one that already requires belief in magical powers, revelations, and worship of a specific person. They were rendered receptive to the incarnation of the "charismatic authority," less by the economic dependency created by medicaid and social security, more by the emotional dependency created by evangelical religion. While most evangelicals would be offended by this remark, and some continue to see Trump as something of a "false profit," one does not support Trump because he will make incremental progress on the issues plaguing the US, but because he will abolish the issues, once and for all, with ... what? There the thinking stops, because that is where it always stops with the imprecations hurled at the contesting incarnation of evil to be avoided, whether Obama or Clinton, and the imperative "have faith!"
A subtle, but telling example has come up recently. The Washington Post ran a story about a rally Trump has held with a Veterans group. The full quote, as they transcribe it runs like this:
"When you talk about the mental health problems, when people come back from war and combat, they see things that maybe a lot of the folks in this room have seen many times over. And you're strong and you can handle it, but a lot of people can't handle it," the Republican presidential nominee told an audience of military veterans at an event in Northern Virginia on Monday morning. "And they see horror stories, they see events that you couldn’t see in a movie — nobody would believe it."
The Post ran the headline, "Trump suggests military members with mental health issues aren’t ‘strong’ and ‘can’t handle it.'" At least one veteran in the group objected to their interpretation of the statement. "Marine Staff Sgt. Chad Robichaux," the post reports, "whose question Trump was answering in his remarks, issued a statement after the event calling it "sickening that anyone would twist Mr. Trump’s comments." Robichaux, who suffered from PTSD, added: 'I took his comments to be thoughtful and understanding of the struggles many veterans have.'" Whether Trump's comments are "thoughtful and understanding" I will leave to the interpretation of others, but I would suggest they reveal one characteristic -- they are ambiguous. To play the English teacher for a moment, Trump speaks with very broad nouns (e.g. "people" and "folks") and a plethora of pronouns. The first pronoun "they" as in in "they see things" -- refers to the "people [coming] back from war and combat." The second pronoun "you" -- as in "you're strong" -- seems to refer to "a lot of the folks in this room," his immediate audience, and he compliments them saying "you can handle it." He then shifts the reference to "a lot of people can't handle it." Who are these people? Are we still speaking of people who "come back from war and combat?" Are we still characterizing his immediate audience, or another "group of people?" Is he expressing sympathy for those in the audience that "couldn't handle it" or is he vilifying, present company excluded, those who "can't handle it?" Hard to tell, and so one can interpret it more or less as the Post interpreted it, or as Staff Sgt. Robichaux interpreted it, and it probably depends upon one's predisposition to Trump just how it gets interpreted. For those of us who see nothing particularly great about Trump, who see his remark as mostly cliche ridden and inarticulate babble, we find it puzzling and disturbing. For those who have invested their faith in Trump, however, the remark tells them precisely what they want to hear.
What Trump doesn't say, of course, is what, if anything, he would do for veterans, particularly those who aren't strong and who couldn't handle it. According to Wikipedia, for example, "in 2013, the United States Department of Veterans Affairs released a study that covered suicides from 1999 to 2010, which showed that roughly 22 veterans were committing suicide per day, or one every 65 minutes. Some sources suggest that this rate may be undercounting suicides. A recent analysis found a suicide rate among veterans of about 30 per 100,000 population per year, compared with the civilian rate of 14 per 100,000." Additionally, "a study published in the Cleveland Clinic Journal of Medicine found that, 'combat veterans are not only more likely to have suicidal ideation, often associated with posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and depression, but they are more likely to act on a suicidal plan. Especially since veterans may be less likely to seek help from a mental health professional.'" Indeed, it does seem like a "a lot of people," and all of this, of course, is merely (merely!) a subset of the larger problem of our military interventions, their economic and human cost, and the failures of our health care systems to fully accommodate returning veterans. Despite any sympathy that Trump might extend to veterans who have seen "horror stories" or "events you couldn't see in a movie," it is unlikely the problem will simply dissipate with the election under the sheer magnificent awesomeness of Trump's aura. Whoever takes office must create policy to actually address the problem, such as it is, and Clinton, for all her bureaucratic wonkishness, seems predisposed to do just that. Trump, on the other hand, seem predisposed to do ... what? There the thinking stops, because that is where it always stops with the imprecations hurled at the contesting evil to be avoided, whether Obama or Clinton, and the imperative "have faith!" Of course, once in power, Trump will no longer have need of the conspiracies, and they will dissipate, but the REAL problems that affect REAL people? Probably not, but it is also irrelevant to those who have invested their faith in Trump. He has extended a "call to worship," and the object of veneration is Trump himself. He holds "magical powers," and will make "revelations" at the appropriate time, and for those who believe, who truly believe, he will make them "great again." Amen.
Then too there's a sort of magical thinking, one that ascribes to the "great man" or the "great woman" an ability that no man or woman could possess. Let me explain. On November 15th, the day after the election, we will wake up with a new president. Regardless who that president might be, he or she will be confronted with several intractable and contentious issues. To list just a few: (1) deteriorating race relations, (2) immigration reform and war refuges, (3) the middle east and US foreign policy, to include our military interventions, (4) trade policy, (5) escalating Russian adventurism, (6) the environment, (7) the distribution of wealth and its economic effects, (8) health care, and (9) whatever else comes up. Though some of the rhetoric surrounding these problems might dissipate, none of the problems themselves will just go away after the election. No democrat that I've heard or read really believes that Clinton will come into office and the problems will simply yield to her greatness. They enumerate policy proposals that will, in one way or another, "address" the "issues." One can have, quite legitimately, different takes on each of these issues, and because they all have been with us for some time, I will venture the assumption that there are no quick and easy (no magical) solutions. No matter who takes office, there is a prevailing assumption among democrats that she will "inherit," lock stock and barrel, all of the intractable and contentious issues. No matter what one might think of her personally, she has the temperament and the policy experience to address them.
Trump supporters, however, continue to see him as the "great man," and for those of us who see nothing particularly great about him, who just don't get it, find that puzzling and disturbing. Part of it, perhaps, can be attributed to Trump himself. He sees himself as the "great man" -- I alone can solve -- and invests himself with "powers" that exceed those of normal human beings. He presents himself almost exclusively as a Charismatic Leader. George Will touches on his in his editorial the other day. “'Charismatic authority,' wrote Max Weber in 1915, seven years before Mussolini’s march on Rome, causes the governed to submit “because of their belief in the extraordinary quality of the specific person . . . . Charismatic rule thus rests upon the belief in magical powers, revelations and hero worship.' A demagogue’s success requires a receptive demos." Will, a conservative writer, blames the receptivity of his supporters on the prep work by democrats -- that is to say, "progressivism’s success in changing America’s social norms and national character by de-stigmatizing dependency." Perhaps, to some degree, but I think a bigger culprit is the religious milieu his supporters inhabit -- one that already requires belief in magical powers, revelations, and worship of a specific person. They were rendered receptive to the incarnation of the "charismatic authority," less by the economic dependency created by medicaid and social security, more by the emotional dependency created by evangelical religion. While most evangelicals would be offended by this remark, and some continue to see Trump as something of a "false profit," one does not support Trump because he will make incremental progress on the issues plaguing the US, but because he will abolish the issues, once and for all, with ... what? There the thinking stops, because that is where it always stops with the imprecations hurled at the contesting incarnation of evil to be avoided, whether Obama or Clinton, and the imperative "have faith!"
A subtle, but telling example has come up recently. The Washington Post ran a story about a rally Trump has held with a Veterans group. The full quote, as they transcribe it runs like this:
"When you talk about the mental health problems, when people come back from war and combat, they see things that maybe a lot of the folks in this room have seen many times over. And you're strong and you can handle it, but a lot of people can't handle it," the Republican presidential nominee told an audience of military veterans at an event in Northern Virginia on Monday morning. "And they see horror stories, they see events that you couldn’t see in a movie — nobody would believe it."
The Post ran the headline, "Trump suggests military members with mental health issues aren’t ‘strong’ and ‘can’t handle it.'" At least one veteran in the group objected to their interpretation of the statement. "Marine Staff Sgt. Chad Robichaux," the post reports, "whose question Trump was answering in his remarks, issued a statement after the event calling it "sickening that anyone would twist Mr. Trump’s comments." Robichaux, who suffered from PTSD, added: 'I took his comments to be thoughtful and understanding of the struggles many veterans have.'" Whether Trump's comments are "thoughtful and understanding" I will leave to the interpretation of others, but I would suggest they reveal one characteristic -- they are ambiguous. To play the English teacher for a moment, Trump speaks with very broad nouns (e.g. "people" and "folks") and a plethora of pronouns. The first pronoun "they" as in in "they see things" -- refers to the "people [coming] back from war and combat." The second pronoun "you" -- as in "you're strong" -- seems to refer to "a lot of the folks in this room," his immediate audience, and he compliments them saying "you can handle it." He then shifts the reference to "a lot of people can't handle it." Who are these people? Are we still speaking of people who "come back from war and combat?" Are we still characterizing his immediate audience, or another "group of people?" Is he expressing sympathy for those in the audience that "couldn't handle it" or is he vilifying, present company excluded, those who "can't handle it?" Hard to tell, and so one can interpret it more or less as the Post interpreted it, or as Staff Sgt. Robichaux interpreted it, and it probably depends upon one's predisposition to Trump just how it gets interpreted. For those of us who see nothing particularly great about Trump, who see his remark as mostly cliche ridden and inarticulate babble, we find it puzzling and disturbing. For those who have invested their faith in Trump, however, the remark tells them precisely what they want to hear.
What Trump doesn't say, of course, is what, if anything, he would do for veterans, particularly those who aren't strong and who couldn't handle it. According to Wikipedia, for example, "in 2013, the United States Department of Veterans Affairs released a study that covered suicides from 1999 to 2010, which showed that roughly 22 veterans were committing suicide per day, or one every 65 minutes. Some sources suggest that this rate may be undercounting suicides. A recent analysis found a suicide rate among veterans of about 30 per 100,000 population per year, compared with the civilian rate of 14 per 100,000." Additionally, "a study published in the Cleveland Clinic Journal of Medicine found that, 'combat veterans are not only more likely to have suicidal ideation, often associated with posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and depression, but they are more likely to act on a suicidal plan. Especially since veterans may be less likely to seek help from a mental health professional.'" Indeed, it does seem like a "a lot of people," and all of this, of course, is merely (merely!) a subset of the larger problem of our military interventions, their economic and human cost, and the failures of our health care systems to fully accommodate returning veterans. Despite any sympathy that Trump might extend to veterans who have seen "horror stories" or "events you couldn't see in a movie," it is unlikely the problem will simply dissipate with the election under the sheer magnificent awesomeness of Trump's aura. Whoever takes office must create policy to actually address the problem, such as it is, and Clinton, for all her bureaucratic wonkishness, seems predisposed to do just that. Trump, on the other hand, seem predisposed to do ... what? There the thinking stops, because that is where it always stops with the imprecations hurled at the contesting evil to be avoided, whether Obama or Clinton, and the imperative "have faith!" Of course, once in power, Trump will no longer have need of the conspiracies, and they will dissipate, but the REAL problems that affect REAL people? Probably not, but it is also irrelevant to those who have invested their faith in Trump. He has extended a "call to worship," and the object of veneration is Trump himself. He holds "magical powers," and will make "revelations" at the appropriate time, and for those who believe, who truly believe, he will make them "great again." Amen.
Saturday, October 1, 2016
The Moral Hazard of Dependency
Paul Krugman in his most recent editorial asks the titular question "how did the Clinton-Trump race get so close?" He assembles the most plausible answers. Race, of course, is a factor, and perhaps the biggest factor. "A lot more Americans than we’d like to imagine are white nationalists at heart," he writes, then goes on to add "implicit appeals to racial hostility have long been at the core of Republican strategy; Mr. Trump became the G.O.P. nominee by saying outright what his opponents tried to convey with dog whistles." The media, of course, is another factor. On the one hand, with its predisposition to "fairness" which led to the so-called "normalization" of her adversary, it also led to the "abnormalization" of Clinton. Krugman is quoting Jonathan Cait, who goes on to say "the news media’s obsession with the emails has, without necessarily intending to do so, conveyed the impression that Clinton committed not just run-of-the-mill political scandals but extraordinary offenses of a historic scale," meanwhile failing to point out a similar scandal in the Bush administration. That scandal resulted in the deletion of not 30 thousand emails, but rather 22 million emails, "systematically flouting the same public-records principle that Clinton evaded" on a much larger historical scale. Ditto the media's recent obsession with the foundation, which Krugman notes, coincides with her fall in the polls, "an extraordinary series of hostile news stories about how various aspects of Mrs. Clinton’s life 'raise questions' or 'cast shadows,' conveying an impression of terrible things without saying anything that could be refuted," meanwhile all but ignoring the activity of the Trump Foundation which appears to be little more than a money laundering-tax avoidance scheme.
Altogether, the media, with its predisposition of "fairness" has created an unmerited "false equivalency," and though there seem to be attempts to back away from it -- with traditionally conservative media outlets like the Cleveland Plain Dealer endorsing Clinton or the normally apolitical USA Today "un-endorsing" Trump -- the real damage has nevertheless been done. In the meantime, it is interesting to read George Will's comments in today's Post. Among conservative intellectuals, there is a sort of incredulousness that conservatism and the republican party have degraded themselves with the nomination of Trump, what he calls "his piratical capture" of the conservative party. "At the risk of taking Trump’s words more seriously than he does," he writes, "on some matters he is to Clinton’s left regarding big government powered by an unbridled presidency" -- his trade policies appealing to "faux conservatives comfortable with presidents dictating what Americans can import and purchase at what prices, and where U.S. corporations can operate" -- his social welfare policies, on social security in particular, revealing that "he, like Clinton, is for enriching this entitlement’s benefits" thereby enlarging "progressivism’s success in changing America’s social norms and national character by de-stigmatizing dependency." There is, of course, a legitimate debate to be had regarding the moral hazard associated with "dependency," and I suspect Will would relish the debate, but it is not one to be had with an "exhausted volcano, the intellectual staleness of its recycled candidate unchallenged because a generation of younger Democratic leaders barely exists." One would almost agree. Conservative outlets can grit their teeth and endorse Clinton, because, as I have said before, on core economic issues that appeal to the biggest of the big money conservatives, particularly trade, she is perhaps to the right of the current republican nominee. How odd?
Will, however, ignores other aspects of his party's decay, not least a sort of intellectual flabbiness. At one point in my life, I remember discussing "institutional core values" at some length, and Will touches on two "core values" of the republican party -- laissez faire economics and individual accountability. The first, I've argued, is something of a false idea, in part because the "economy" is a social construct comprised of the existing rules-regulations-laws that inevitably favor some over others. Will, for example, criticizes Trump's support for the Supreme Court’s 2005 Kelo decision diluting property rights by vastly expanding government’s powers of eminent domain." Trump supports it "100 percent," surprise! because it allows government agencies to use "its eminent domain authority to seize private property to sell to private developers." As a private developer, with the "means" to sway local government, that legal decision favors him over small property owners without the "means" to resist local government. Will's consistency, however, is admirable, but concerning. Insofar as "property rights," particularly "intellectual property rights," as defined in existing law, give pharmaceutical companies monopoly protection over particular "life saving drugs," like epinephrine, allowing what can only be described as "price gouging." There are existing rules-regulations-laws that inevitably favor some over others, and the only real political questions are these: who is favored? and how? and what, if desired, can be done to shift the balance? One can argue whether the system is "rigged," but rigged against whom? and for what reason? I would argue that the economic system is "rigged" in the same way that basketball is "rigged" in favor of "tallness." The rules of basketball apply equally to all, and of course it is possible for a tall man to fail and a short man to succeed, but let's be honest. It takes such extraordinary ability for those who start short to succeed in basketball that for most it's simply impossible, and it seems a bit disingenuous to hold short people accountable for their lack of representation in the upper echelons of the NBA. Likewise, it takes such extraordinary ability for those who start short, the "poor," to advance in our current economy that it seems impossible, and so too it seems a bit disingenuous to hold "poor" people completely accountable for their economic condition and the cultural malaise economic stagnation or regression creates.
Will, however, complete ignores the other aspects of his party's decay. With Nixon and the southern strategy, likewise with Reagan and what might be called the evangelical strategy, the conservative party embraced an incipient racial and religious bigotry -- what has been called social conservatism -- for the sake of electoral wins that would otherwise be unavailable to them. It is unlikely that the vast majority of Americans would support the republican economic agenda, laid bare, insofar as it so clearly favors the rich at the expense of the working class and the poor. If the current malaise takes "a charlatan’s successful selling of his fabulousness," it took another charlatan's successful selling of a demonstrably false notion, trickle down economics, to set aside any real discussion of a monied elite's economic agenda and refocus the popular republican party on bread and circus social issues. Although Trump's rhetoric is infinitely less sophisticated than Reagan's, infinitely more narcissistic and messianic, trickle down economics is no less a promise to the people, the demos, that "“I will give you everything. I will give you what you’ve been looking for for 50 years.” There was some trickle down, of course, but it wasn't quite the "golden flow" that the people expected. At the same time, social conservatism gathered steam during Bill Clinton's admittedly smarmy presidency, and subsequently provided a convenient focus for the resentment following the economic collapse of the Bush years. Clearly, it's their fault, and we all know who "they" are. With the election of Obama, the Americans who are "white nationalists at heart" could feel their nation had been co-opted and focus an ineffectual resentment on our first black president, and the religious conservatives could focus their resentment on the prevailing social trends toward expanded civil rights for gays and all those who do not hold "true" christian values. It's not surprising that the two coalesced into the conspiracy-theory suppositions that Obama was not "really" an American, but rather a secret a muslim operative bent on implementing sharia law.
Clinton is correct, I think, in her condemnation of the republican party not only as the party of failed economic ideas (the admittedly old aunt-ish pun of "trumped up trickle down") but also as the party of racial and religiously inspired intolerance. Will imagines that "the American project was to construct a constitutional regime whose institutional architecture would guarantee the limited government implied by the Founders’ philosophy: Government is instituted to “secure” (the Declaration of Independence) preexisting natural rights." If those "natural rights" are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, I would agree, but go on to ask "natural rights for whom?" There are those who believe -- sincerely believe -- that "rights" are (or ought to be) hierarchical, with white christian men on the top with not only the "right," but the duty to exercise "natural" paternal authority over all others. Even if the modern conservative rejects the imperious racism of the "white man's burden" -- even if he extends the basic rights of "life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness" to all -- there still remains a basic flaw in contemporary thinking on the limitations of government. The founding fathers could believe that a "right to life" could be secured through a simple negative liberty, being "free from" government execution without due process. But does that "secure" the right to life in today's world? To take just one example, one that is somewhat contentious, medical science has progressed beyond prayer, a poltice and blood-letting as the standard of care, and we should remember that the founding fathers of our country could not have possibly imagined the rise of the existing health care systems, with its complex entanglement of employers, insurance providers, big pharma, profit and non-profit hospitals. What does it mean, however, to turn away from someone in need of life-saving medical care simply because they do not have benefited employment, or the right insurance, or access to the right right drugs, or sufficient means to pay for insurance or the co-payments of insurance without impoverishing themselves? Is that a failure to "secure" the right to life? Can we ignore the government's role in the present reality where drug prices are kept artificially high by one set of laws protecting intellectual property while another set of laws requires that we insure ourselves at escalating prices to mitigate the escalating cost not only of health care itself, but the escalating cost of personal bankruptcy to the health care system? I do not know how the founding fathers would have reacted to the complex entanglement of today's health care systems, but that is my point. We do not live in the world of our founding fathers. We live in a present reality, and like it or not, we must contend with it.
In the end, most do not like it, particularly the conservative party. In a recent Vox conversation between Sean Illing and Mark Lilla, there was one telling exchange. Illing remarked, "what’s interesting to me is how little ideology has to do with Trump’s popularity. His campaign is largely a negation — of the present, of the direction of the country, of the establishment. That Trump has virtually no solutions or plan for the future seems to be an afterthought to his supporters." I would disagree some with his assertion that Trump's campaign lacks an "ideology." I put ideology in scare quotes, in part because it is the ideology of any aspiring messianic demagogue. The present reality too complex to really fully comprehend, and so, to many, the world seems to be on the verge of apocalypse. A hyperbolic conservative media has contributed to this sense of impending doom, but it takes a fully narcissistic personality to believe -- sincerely believe -- that he is the chosen one. Of course -- of course! -- he is not the chosen one, and anything he puts forward that has any resemblance to a "policy prescription," quickly reveals itself to be utter nonsense. Even his vaunted trade prescriptions are based on a fundamental errors, or at least don't sufficiently account for what would likely happen in the present reality if they were actually implemented. His confidence in his "solutions" can only be described as the Dunning-Kruger effect full blown. To give it a diagnostic sound, Trump has "a cognitive bias in which low-ability individuals suffer from illusory superiority, mistakenly assessing their ability as much higher than it really is. Dunning and Kruger attributed this [to the] inability of those of low ability to recognize their ineptitude and evaluate their ability accurately." Of course Trump is not stupid, but one suspects that he has lived in a bubble of sycophants his "entire adult life," one that has reinforced his illusory superiority and filtered out the sorts of meaningful criticism that would enable him to self-appraise, as evidenced by his over-the-top reactions to anything that pops his bubble, but that is, as so many have noted, beside the point. It is the Dunning-Druger effect itself -- the absolute, unwavering sincerity of Trump's belief in himself as the chosen one -- that moves his following.
Nevertheless, Illing is largely correct. Trump's campaign "ideology" is largely the non-ideology of "negation," particularly of the present reality. Mark Lilla's response is equally telling. He suggests that many believe "all the changes wrought by a global economy and the Internet and mass migration will undermine our culture." He adds, "it's quite natural that unless there's a picture of the future that is compelling before them, they're going to feel an urge to return to something that they believe is familiar." Trump represents, in short, a reaction against the present reality. Politico reports that Trump's populist rhetoric "is intended to appeal to college-educated middle-class voters who tell pollsters that they believe there are 'two sets of rules — one for insiders, another for the rest of us.'" As Politico goes on to write, Trump called out “the special interests, the lobbyists and the corrupt corporate media that have rigged the system against everyday Americans, and they’ve rigged it for a long time.” There's a certain truth to his assertions. Though I can't quite believe it is an "intention driven conspiracy" of the "powerful" against the "weak" -- there are too many conflicting interests even among the powerful -- I do believe the present reality favors special interests over everyday Americans. It is difficult, however, at least for this college educated middle class voter, to suspend reality long enough to believe that Trump can or would address the core issues. Unless we are willing to actually descend into the apocalypse and rebuild a simpler world from scratch, one must contend with the complexities of the present realities. Nothing Trump has said allows me to believe, even for a moment, that he has the intellectual capacity to actually understand the present realities, much less amend them without inviting catastrophe. Indeed, as Lilla suggests, "in the modern world, anti-intellectualism is essential to the forces of reaction. Because it's possible to blame all these changes on the articulate class." When Trump attacks the "elites," he is appealing "to people who are not articulate, " but he also reassures them. "While they may not be able to argue with their adversaries, " Lilla suggests, "they have a kind of preliterate virtue that literacy and intellectual life has robbed them of. Then a kind of holy ignorance emerges, which is a sign that you are the saving remnant." When he claims to be "taking on big business and big media and big donors," and then adds "we’re taking them on for you,” he is appealing not only to a sort of virtue, but to his own messianic stature, to all those who want to believe in him as their personal savior. One who can deliver them from the disturbing complexities of a present reality that doesn't serve them, that they're powerless to understand, much less correct.
So Will too is correct:
“Charismatic authority,” wrote Max Weber in 1915, seven years before Mussolini’s march on Rome, causes the governed to submit “because of their belief in the extraordinary quality of the specific person . . . . Charismatic rule thus rests upon the belief in magical powers, revelations and hero worship.” A demagogue’s success requires a receptive demos, and Trump’s ascendancy reflects progressivism’s success in changing America’s social norms and national character by de-stigmatizing dependency.
Well, Will is partially correct. I don't think one can lay the blame the decay on progressives alone, and besides isn't that simply a projection of conservatism's problems onto others? Trump's success requires a demos brow beaten into receptivity by social conservatism -- a demos irradiated by a conservative media that has our country always on the verge of apocalypse because of America's changing "social norms," not least the disruptions the natural hierarchy of civil rights and sexual norms with gay rights -- a demos immersed in an anti-intellectual "holy ignorance" that denies not only the secular humanism that would challenge the literal interpretation of the bible, but also fundamental science -- a demos already deeply vested in "magical powers, revelations" and "worship," not of secular heroes per se, but certainly a "personal savior" -- a demos already well prepared to believe, with a broad extension of faith, "in the extraordinary quality of the specific person." It is a moral hazard of dependency, a different kind and magnitude of dependency, but nevertheless giving one's self over to the authority of another.
Altogether, the media, with its predisposition of "fairness" has created an unmerited "false equivalency," and though there seem to be attempts to back away from it -- with traditionally conservative media outlets like the Cleveland Plain Dealer endorsing Clinton or the normally apolitical USA Today "un-endorsing" Trump -- the real damage has nevertheless been done. In the meantime, it is interesting to read George Will's comments in today's Post. Among conservative intellectuals, there is a sort of incredulousness that conservatism and the republican party have degraded themselves with the nomination of Trump, what he calls "his piratical capture" of the conservative party. "At the risk of taking Trump’s words more seriously than he does," he writes, "on some matters he is to Clinton’s left regarding big government powered by an unbridled presidency" -- his trade policies appealing to "faux conservatives comfortable with presidents dictating what Americans can import and purchase at what prices, and where U.S. corporations can operate" -- his social welfare policies, on social security in particular, revealing that "he, like Clinton, is for enriching this entitlement’s benefits" thereby enlarging "progressivism’s success in changing America’s social norms and national character by de-stigmatizing dependency." There is, of course, a legitimate debate to be had regarding the moral hazard associated with "dependency," and I suspect Will would relish the debate, but it is not one to be had with an "exhausted volcano, the intellectual staleness of its recycled candidate unchallenged because a generation of younger Democratic leaders barely exists." One would almost agree. Conservative outlets can grit their teeth and endorse Clinton, because, as I have said before, on core economic issues that appeal to the biggest of the big money conservatives, particularly trade, she is perhaps to the right of the current republican nominee. How odd?
Will, however, ignores other aspects of his party's decay, not least a sort of intellectual flabbiness. At one point in my life, I remember discussing "institutional core values" at some length, and Will touches on two "core values" of the republican party -- laissez faire economics and individual accountability. The first, I've argued, is something of a false idea, in part because the "economy" is a social construct comprised of the existing rules-regulations-laws that inevitably favor some over others. Will, for example, criticizes Trump's support for the Supreme Court’s 2005 Kelo decision diluting property rights by vastly expanding government’s powers of eminent domain." Trump supports it "100 percent," surprise! because it allows government agencies to use "its eminent domain authority to seize private property to sell to private developers." As a private developer, with the "means" to sway local government, that legal decision favors him over small property owners without the "means" to resist local government. Will's consistency, however, is admirable, but concerning. Insofar as "property rights," particularly "intellectual property rights," as defined in existing law, give pharmaceutical companies monopoly protection over particular "life saving drugs," like epinephrine, allowing what can only be described as "price gouging." There are existing rules-regulations-laws that inevitably favor some over others, and the only real political questions are these: who is favored? and how? and what, if desired, can be done to shift the balance? One can argue whether the system is "rigged," but rigged against whom? and for what reason? I would argue that the economic system is "rigged" in the same way that basketball is "rigged" in favor of "tallness." The rules of basketball apply equally to all, and of course it is possible for a tall man to fail and a short man to succeed, but let's be honest. It takes such extraordinary ability for those who start short to succeed in basketball that for most it's simply impossible, and it seems a bit disingenuous to hold short people accountable for their lack of representation in the upper echelons of the NBA. Likewise, it takes such extraordinary ability for those who start short, the "poor," to advance in our current economy that it seems impossible, and so too it seems a bit disingenuous to hold "poor" people completely accountable for their economic condition and the cultural malaise economic stagnation or regression creates.
Will, however, complete ignores the other aspects of his party's decay. With Nixon and the southern strategy, likewise with Reagan and what might be called the evangelical strategy, the conservative party embraced an incipient racial and religious bigotry -- what has been called social conservatism -- for the sake of electoral wins that would otherwise be unavailable to them. It is unlikely that the vast majority of Americans would support the republican economic agenda, laid bare, insofar as it so clearly favors the rich at the expense of the working class and the poor. If the current malaise takes "a charlatan’s successful selling of his fabulousness," it took another charlatan's successful selling of a demonstrably false notion, trickle down economics, to set aside any real discussion of a monied elite's economic agenda and refocus the popular republican party on bread and circus social issues. Although Trump's rhetoric is infinitely less sophisticated than Reagan's, infinitely more narcissistic and messianic, trickle down economics is no less a promise to the people, the demos, that "“I will give you everything. I will give you what you’ve been looking for for 50 years.” There was some trickle down, of course, but it wasn't quite the "golden flow" that the people expected. At the same time, social conservatism gathered steam during Bill Clinton's admittedly smarmy presidency, and subsequently provided a convenient focus for the resentment following the economic collapse of the Bush years. Clearly, it's their fault, and we all know who "they" are. With the election of Obama, the Americans who are "white nationalists at heart" could feel their nation had been co-opted and focus an ineffectual resentment on our first black president, and the religious conservatives could focus their resentment on the prevailing social trends toward expanded civil rights for gays and all those who do not hold "true" christian values. It's not surprising that the two coalesced into the conspiracy-theory suppositions that Obama was not "really" an American, but rather a secret a muslim operative bent on implementing sharia law.
Clinton is correct, I think, in her condemnation of the republican party not only as the party of failed economic ideas (the admittedly old aunt-ish pun of "trumped up trickle down") but also as the party of racial and religiously inspired intolerance. Will imagines that "the American project was to construct a constitutional regime whose institutional architecture would guarantee the limited government implied by the Founders’ philosophy: Government is instituted to “secure” (the Declaration of Independence) preexisting natural rights." If those "natural rights" are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, I would agree, but go on to ask "natural rights for whom?" There are those who believe -- sincerely believe -- that "rights" are (or ought to be) hierarchical, with white christian men on the top with not only the "right," but the duty to exercise "natural" paternal authority over all others. Even if the modern conservative rejects the imperious racism of the "white man's burden" -- even if he extends the basic rights of "life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness" to all -- there still remains a basic flaw in contemporary thinking on the limitations of government. The founding fathers could believe that a "right to life" could be secured through a simple negative liberty, being "free from" government execution without due process. But does that "secure" the right to life in today's world? To take just one example, one that is somewhat contentious, medical science has progressed beyond prayer, a poltice and blood-letting as the standard of care, and we should remember that the founding fathers of our country could not have possibly imagined the rise of the existing health care systems, with its complex entanglement of employers, insurance providers, big pharma, profit and non-profit hospitals. What does it mean, however, to turn away from someone in need of life-saving medical care simply because they do not have benefited employment, or the right insurance, or access to the right right drugs, or sufficient means to pay for insurance or the co-payments of insurance without impoverishing themselves? Is that a failure to "secure" the right to life? Can we ignore the government's role in the present reality where drug prices are kept artificially high by one set of laws protecting intellectual property while another set of laws requires that we insure ourselves at escalating prices to mitigate the escalating cost not only of health care itself, but the escalating cost of personal bankruptcy to the health care system? I do not know how the founding fathers would have reacted to the complex entanglement of today's health care systems, but that is my point. We do not live in the world of our founding fathers. We live in a present reality, and like it or not, we must contend with it.
In the end, most do not like it, particularly the conservative party. In a recent Vox conversation between Sean Illing and Mark Lilla, there was one telling exchange. Illing remarked, "what’s interesting to me is how little ideology has to do with Trump’s popularity. His campaign is largely a negation — of the present, of the direction of the country, of the establishment. That Trump has virtually no solutions or plan for the future seems to be an afterthought to his supporters." I would disagree some with his assertion that Trump's campaign lacks an "ideology." I put ideology in scare quotes, in part because it is the ideology of any aspiring messianic demagogue. The present reality too complex to really fully comprehend, and so, to many, the world seems to be on the verge of apocalypse. A hyperbolic conservative media has contributed to this sense of impending doom, but it takes a fully narcissistic personality to believe -- sincerely believe -- that he is the chosen one. Of course -- of course! -- he is not the chosen one, and anything he puts forward that has any resemblance to a "policy prescription," quickly reveals itself to be utter nonsense. Even his vaunted trade prescriptions are based on a fundamental errors, or at least don't sufficiently account for what would likely happen in the present reality if they were actually implemented. His confidence in his "solutions" can only be described as the Dunning-Kruger effect full blown. To give it a diagnostic sound, Trump has "a cognitive bias in which low-ability individuals suffer from illusory superiority, mistakenly assessing their ability as much higher than it really is. Dunning and Kruger attributed this [to the] inability of those of low ability to recognize their ineptitude and evaluate their ability accurately." Of course Trump is not stupid, but one suspects that he has lived in a bubble of sycophants his "entire adult life," one that has reinforced his illusory superiority and filtered out the sorts of meaningful criticism that would enable him to self-appraise, as evidenced by his over-the-top reactions to anything that pops his bubble, but that is, as so many have noted, beside the point. It is the Dunning-Druger effect itself -- the absolute, unwavering sincerity of Trump's belief in himself as the chosen one -- that moves his following.
Nevertheless, Illing is largely correct. Trump's campaign "ideology" is largely the non-ideology of "negation," particularly of the present reality. Mark Lilla's response is equally telling. He suggests that many believe "all the changes wrought by a global economy and the Internet and mass migration will undermine our culture." He adds, "it's quite natural that unless there's a picture of the future that is compelling before them, they're going to feel an urge to return to something that they believe is familiar." Trump represents, in short, a reaction against the present reality. Politico reports that Trump's populist rhetoric "is intended to appeal to college-educated middle-class voters who tell pollsters that they believe there are 'two sets of rules — one for insiders, another for the rest of us.'" As Politico goes on to write, Trump called out “the special interests, the lobbyists and the corrupt corporate media that have rigged the system against everyday Americans, and they’ve rigged it for a long time.” There's a certain truth to his assertions. Though I can't quite believe it is an "intention driven conspiracy" of the "powerful" against the "weak" -- there are too many conflicting interests even among the powerful -- I do believe the present reality favors special interests over everyday Americans. It is difficult, however, at least for this college educated middle class voter, to suspend reality long enough to believe that Trump can or would address the core issues. Unless we are willing to actually descend into the apocalypse and rebuild a simpler world from scratch, one must contend with the complexities of the present realities. Nothing Trump has said allows me to believe, even for a moment, that he has the intellectual capacity to actually understand the present realities, much less amend them without inviting catastrophe. Indeed, as Lilla suggests, "in the modern world, anti-intellectualism is essential to the forces of reaction. Because it's possible to blame all these changes on the articulate class." When Trump attacks the "elites," he is appealing "to people who are not articulate, " but he also reassures them. "While they may not be able to argue with their adversaries, " Lilla suggests, "they have a kind of preliterate virtue that literacy and intellectual life has robbed them of. Then a kind of holy ignorance emerges, which is a sign that you are the saving remnant." When he claims to be "taking on big business and big media and big donors," and then adds "we’re taking them on for you,” he is appealing not only to a sort of virtue, but to his own messianic stature, to all those who want to believe in him as their personal savior. One who can deliver them from the disturbing complexities of a present reality that doesn't serve them, that they're powerless to understand, much less correct.
So Will too is correct:
“Charismatic authority,” wrote Max Weber in 1915, seven years before Mussolini’s march on Rome, causes the governed to submit “because of their belief in the extraordinary quality of the specific person . . . . Charismatic rule thus rests upon the belief in magical powers, revelations and hero worship.” A demagogue’s success requires a receptive demos, and Trump’s ascendancy reflects progressivism’s success in changing America’s social norms and national character by de-stigmatizing dependency.
Well, Will is partially correct. I don't think one can lay the blame the decay on progressives alone, and besides isn't that simply a projection of conservatism's problems onto others? Trump's success requires a demos brow beaten into receptivity by social conservatism -- a demos irradiated by a conservative media that has our country always on the verge of apocalypse because of America's changing "social norms," not least the disruptions the natural hierarchy of civil rights and sexual norms with gay rights -- a demos immersed in an anti-intellectual "holy ignorance" that denies not only the secular humanism that would challenge the literal interpretation of the bible, but also fundamental science -- a demos already deeply vested in "magical powers, revelations" and "worship," not of secular heroes per se, but certainly a "personal savior" -- a demos already well prepared to believe, with a broad extension of faith, "in the extraordinary quality of the specific person." It is a moral hazard of dependency, a different kind and magnitude of dependency, but nevertheless giving one's self over to the authority of another.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)